Thai boy is bird flu’s seventh fatality; Pakistan detects virus in chickens

DANIEL LOVERING
Jan. 27, 2004

BANGKOK, Thailand (AP) – Thailand confirmed its first fatality from bird flu Monday, raising the number of deaths in Asia from the disease to seven – the deadliest outbreak since 1997.

Laos become the ninth country to report infections after a sample sent to a laboratory in Vietnam tested positive for the disease, Singkham Phounvisay, director of the country’s Livestock Department, said Tuesday. The tests were conducted after hundreds of chickens died on farms, most of them around the Lao capital of Vientiane.

China planned to ban poultry from Indonesia and Pakistan, two of the latest countries to join the growing list of areas affected by bird flu, a state-run newspaper reported Tuesday.

“Fowl, birds and related products arriving in China from these countries will be destroyed under the supervision of the quarantine bureau,” the Beijing Youth Daily said, citing an unnamed official from the Ministry of Agriculture.

The report did not say when the ban would begin or what the related products were. Telephone calls to the ministry were not answered and its website didn’t have any information on the action.

No cases of bird flu have been reported in China, which has already stopped shipments from Cambodia, Thailand, Japan, South Korea and Vietnam to prevent the disease from spreading to its poultry stocks. Taiwan has reported a milder strain of the flu, but the mainland has not said anything about poultry bans from the island.

Pakistan reported its first cases on Monday, with a government official saying that 1.5 million chickens died from a strain of the virus different than the one blamed for the human fatalities. Bird flu has triggered mass slaughter of chickens across Asia.

Thailand confirmed the death of a six-year-old boy who fell ill after playing with chickens in his village. The Thai government was awaiting test results to determine whether five other deaths were caused by avian flu, as suspected.

The World Health Organization said the search for a vaccine had been set back because the virus has mutated. A bird flu strain detected in Hong Kong in 1997 no longer can be used as the key to producing a vaccine, the WHO said.

The Hong Kong outbreak marked the first time scientists had documented that bird flu could be caught by humans. Six people died in the 1997 outbreak, the deadliest known previous outbreak.

Scientists believe people get the disease through contact with sick birds. Although there has been no evidence of human-to-human transmission, health officials are concerned the disease might mutate further and link with regular influenza to create a disease that could trigger the next human flu pandemic.

“This is now spreading too quickly for anybody to ignore it,” said WHO spokesman Peter Cordingley in Manila, Philippines.

Officials in Bangkok said they were investigating whether the virus might be carried by migratory birds.

In Ottawa, meanwhile, Health Canada issued a travel advisory recommending that Canadians living in or travelling to Asia stay away from live poultry markets. Dr. Arlene King, head of immunization and respiratory disease for Health Canada, said they also are being warned to thoroughly clean and cook chicken.

As well, infectious disease experts at Toronto and Vancouver airports are on the lookout for sick passengers, the department said.

Last week one farmer, Chavalit Pholchamroon, told The Associated Press that chickens owned by a friend in the province of Chachoengsao started dropping dead after coming into close contact with storks that he said migrate from Siberia every year.

The birds, which arrived in November, feed in rice fields and wetlands, some located near chicken farms.

Captan Boonmanut, the six-year-old Thai boy, became infected in Kanchanaburi province and died Sunday night in a Bangkok hospital.

The boy’s father, a farmer, accused the Thai government of covering up. Thai officials confirmed Friday that the disease had struck, after weeks of denials.

“The government knew, so why didn’t they tell the public so that we could protect ourselves?” Chamnan Boonmanut said in an interview with The Associated Press.

Four other people suspected of having bird flu died in Sukhothai province, the Public Health Ministry said Monday. Officials were also trying to determine if bird flu killed a 56-year-old man who bred fighting cocks.

Asian governments have killed chickens in a desperate bid to contain the disease, with Thailand slaughtering about 10 million chickens and Vietnam more than three million.

The outbreak has devastated Thailand’s chicken export industry – the world’s fourth-largest – which shipped about 500,000 tonnes of chicken worth $1.7 billion Cdn in 2003. Thailand’s biggest markets, Japan and the European Union, have banned its poultry products.

Dr. Prasert Phongcharoen, a WHO adviser and viral disease expert, urged caution in the disposal of chicken carcasses. If infected chickens are thrown in rivers, “the virus could spread to open pig farms and this could result in transmission from pigs to humans,” he said.

The virus would pass more easily from pigs to humans because they are genetically closer, he said.

So far, nine countries have reported some strain of bird flu – Cambodia, Indonesia, Japan, Pakistan, South Korea, Taiwan, Thailand, Vietnam and Laos.

Pakistan’s commissioner for livestock husbandry, Rafaqat Hussain Raja, said Monday that 1.5 million chickens had succumbed to a strain of the virus.

However, an industry official said the disease had killed up to 3.5 million birds.

An official at Pakistan’s WHO office, Faizullah Kakar, said the agency had not confirmed a bird flu outbreak in the country.

The reported Pakistani strain differs from the H5N1 strain blamed for the human fatalities this year, but similar strains have been known to infect humans, WHO’s website said.

Indonesian officials faced accusations of a coverup.

The Jakarta Post reported Monday that Indonesian officials may have suppressed news of the outbreak at the behest of politically connected businessmen.

A team of agricultural experts said in December they provided the government with test results positively identifying the disease. A virologist, Dr. Marthen Malelo, said a powerful “businessmen’s lobby” prevented officials from making the disease public.

Indonesian officials denied the allegations.

“It’s not true. We have zero tolerance for pressure from businessmen. We are talking about the lives of people,” Agriculture Department spokesman Hari Priyono said.

Officials said the country would start killing up to 3.8 million chickens in East Java. Bali already has slaughtered and burned thousands.